The ultimate Christmas dinner

OK it's a little late but then I didn't realise this video was online! I watched it for the first time over Christmas 2007 and then again last year. Heston Blumenthal has quickly become a favourite to watch and someday I hope to be able to get to his restaurant. Until then I'll sit and watch in awe!

Zakim paper

I've been using Zakim for a few years through various W3C standards committees. Nice paper.

Arjuna and the OTS

A couple of comments on my last reminiscence post got me thinking again. One of the things we use to go on about a lot in the early days of the company was the influence we'd had on standards and particularly the Object Transaction Service from the OMG. If you ever compare the two you'll see that by the time the OTS started Graeme, who co-created the Arjuna project (upon which he also got his PhD), was working for Transarc and involved in the standards definition. I remember visiting him in Pittsburgh a few times during that period and hearing a few horror stories about this brain-dead approach being pushed by vendor X and that dumb idea from vendor Y. But I'm sure it was all fun; it was definitely influential on the industry and me personally. When I came to start pushing the OTS in the OMG I did understand what Graeme had been on about with standards processes!

OMG where did the time go?

While writing the previous entry concerning building transactional applications I came across that HP paper by Nigel Edwards. That sent shivers down my spine because I can recall Nigel sharing the office with Stuart and I for months while he got to grips with Arjuna. We were both still doing our PhDs and also in the throws of making the first code release of Arjuna to the world. Here's the announcement for Release 2 (it would appear that our first release predates the web!):

Arjuna (Distr Prog System)

What: Release 2 of Arjuna Distributed Programming System
From: arjuna@newcastle.ac.uk (Arjuna Project)
Date: Mon, 17 May 1993 12:37:34 GMT

        We are pleased to announce the  availability  of a new  version 
of Arjuna:  a programming system for  reliable  distributed  computing, 
and the Arjuna mailing list.

        The software  and the manual  for  the  Arjuna  system  can  be 
obtained by anonymous ftp: arjuna.ncl.ac.uk (128.240.150.1)

Arjuna System

        This beta release of  ArjunaPR2.0  fixes all known bugs present 
in ArjunaPR1.2B that have  been  reported to us or  that we have found, 
and contains only minimal information about how to use the new features 
provided.   This  release  should  be  compilable  with  the  following 
compilers:

        AT&T Cfront Release 2.1, on SunOS 4.1.x,
            (using Sun supplied lex and yacc).
        AT&T Cfront Release 3.0.1, on SunOS 4.1.x and Solaris 2.1,
            (using Sun supplied lex and yacc).
        GCC versions 2.1, 2.2.2, on SunOS 4.1.x,
            (using flex(v2.3.x) and bison).
        Patched GCC version 2.3.3 on SunOS 4.1.x and Solaris 2.1,
            (using flex(v2.3.x) and bison).
        Sun C++ 2.1, on SunOs 4.1.x,
            (using Sun's lex++ and yacc++).
        HP  C++ (B2402 A.02.34), HP-UX 8.07,
            (using HP supplied lex and yacc or lex++ and yacc++).

The major new features are:

        - Faster object store.
        - Support for replicated objects.
        - Memory resident object store.
        - Support for ANSAware (not available via ftp)

        Arjuna supports nested atomic actions (atomic transactions) for 
controlling operations on objects (instances of C++ classes), which can 
potentially be persistent. Arjuna has been implemented in C++ to run on 
stock  platforms  (Unix  on  SUNs,  HPs  etc).  The  software available 
includes  a C++  stub generator  which hides  much  of the  details  of 
client-server  based  programming,  plus  a system  programmer's manual 
containing  details of  how  to  install  Arjuna and  use it  to  build 
fault-tolerant  distributed  applications.  The software and the manual 
can be obtained by anonymous ftp: arjuna.ncl.ac.uk (128.240.150.1)

        Several  enhancements   and   ports  on   various   distributed 
computing platforms are in progress.  We would be pleased  to hear from 
researchers and teachers  interested in using Arjuna.  The programmer's 
manual  contains the  e-mail  addresses for sending  your  comments and 
problem reports.

ANSAware version of Arjuna

The ANSAware version of Arjuna is available from:

Architecture Projects Management Limited
Poseidon House
Castle Park                                  Phone    +44 223 323010
Cambridge                                    Fax      +44 223 359779
CB3 0RD                                      Internet apm@ansa.co.uk
United Kingdom                               UUCP     ...uknet!ansa!apm

Arjuna Mailing List

To enable us to  help people using Arjuna,  an electronic mail list has 
been setup. You can join  the Arjuna mailing list  by sending an e-mail 
message to "mailbase@mailbase.ac.uk" containing:

join arjuna 

For example : join arjuna John Smith

Mail  messages  can  then   be  sent  to  "arjuna@mailbase.ac.uk",  for 
distribution.


Arjuna Project Team
The Department of Computing Science,
The University,
Newcastle upon Tyne.
NE1 7RU, UK.

The work we did with Nigel still seems so fresh in my mind and yet it is so long ago.

Then I also remembered the work on Stabilis that some of our Brazilian PhD students did a few years later. We'd always talked about how the programming model we had in Arjuna was good for building complex applications (and Nigel's work agreed with that), but it took us all by surprise when they presented Stabilis: here was the largest and most complex system (a full relational database) built entirely on Arjuna! This was an impressive demonstration of what was possible with what we'd spent the last 6 years working on.

Definitely a time to reminisce!

Transactions and AIT/TOJ

Jonathan pointed me to a recent discussion on TSS concerning writing transactional resources for non-transactional objects. It expanded into the more general topic of how to write XAResources, which it topical at the moment within Red Hat. Anyway it got me thinking that many of these requests aren't necessarily for "How do I write an XAResource?" but more for "How do I make my data transactional?" These are two different questions: the former infers the latter, but the latter doesn't infer the former. Yes believe it or not but transactions existed before XA came on the scene.

So it got me thinking and I realised that what many of them they really want is something akin to what we did in the original Arjuna system. It didn't have a name back then, since it was the whole reason for doing the Arjuna research, but eventually it became known as Arjuna Integrated Transactions (AIT), or Transactional Objects for Java (TOJ). The use of "it" has not been pushed much (at all) over the past few years, which is a shame because I still think it's a great model. So it may be time to dust it off and bring it back into the light.

Sock and Anti-Sock Pairs

Back when I was hard at work doing my Physics undergraduate degree (a quarter of a century ago!) I remember a few of us finding creative ways to spend the time during the 4 hour practical sessions we had twice a week. Well there are only so many times you can do Millikan's experiment or kill a cat in an enclosed box with a stray beta particle. (OK that last one is something we planned but never quite did for obvious reasons and it still scores high on the "what if?" discussions at reunions.) So what we often did was end up spending hours reading New Scientist.

The one article that has stuck in my mind for that length of time was a brief description of why you end up with odd socks in the wash and usually a piece of fluff. From what I can recall, it talked about spontaneous creation of anti-socks and sock/anti-sock annihilation. To us physics students it appealed on at least two levels: the obvious physics analogies concerning matter and anti-matter, but also the fact that for most of us this was the first time we'd been away from home and having to worry about doing our own washing, much of which was full of fluff and stray socks that we were sure weren't our own! Many times over the years I wish I'd kept that article. I had hoped that the wonder of the digital age would help, but this is the closest I've found.

DOA Program Committee and Topics

I'm chairing DOA 2009 and my co-chairs (Jean-Jacques Dubray and Fabio Panzieri) and I have been finalizing the program committee. Fortunately most of last year's PC have agreed to stay on so we've only had to add a couple of new people. Next step is to figure out the Call for Papers. If you've any thoughts on things you'd like to see at DOA 2009 that maybe weren't covered in the DOA 2008 CfP, let me know. After that we'll have to determine the invited speakers and keynotes. Fun fun fun!